Website redesign and SEO

How to redesign your website with SEO in mind

By Borderless Studio. Updated .

A website redesign can affect search traffic. Reduce avoidable problems by recording what works, retaining useful pages, planning URL changes and testing before launch. Monitor search visibility and enquiries afterwards. Careful preparation helps manage the risk; it cannot guarantee unchanged rankings.

01 / Website redesign and SEO

Before you touch the design: record what works

A redesign is risky mostly because people change things without knowing which ones matter. Start by writing down what you have.

  • A full list of your current URLs, from a site crawl and from your sitemap
  • The pages that bring the most clicks and enquiries, from Search Console and analytics
  • The pages other websites link to, because those links are valuable
  • Current page titles, headings, descriptions and internal links for your top pages
  • A baseline: clicks, impressions and enquiries per month, so you can compare after launch

02 / Website redesign and SEO

Decide what stays

The safest URL is the one that does not change.

  • Keep the web address of every page that already brings enquiries, unless there is a strong reason to change it
  • Keep and improve content that ranks, rather than rewriting it from scratch
  • For pages you merge or retire, record the appropriate action using the URL decisions below.
  • Avoid changing your domain at the same time unless you must. A domain change is a site move of its own, and doing both makes problems harder to trace

03 / Website redesign and SEO

Decide what happens to each existing URL

Create a URL inventory and record a decision for each page. A redesign does not mean every address needs a redirect.

Situation and appropriate action for each existing URL
SituationAppropriate action
Page stays at the same addressKeep the URL and return its real content with HTTP 200.
Page moves permanentlyUse a server-side 301 or 308 redirect to its relevant replacement.
Several pages become oneRedirect to the consolidated page when it genuinely covers the original content.
Page is removed with no suitable replacementReturn HTTP 404 or 410. Offer useful navigation without redirecting visitors to an unrelated page.

Send redirects directly to their final destination. Update internal links and the sitemap to the intended live URLs.

04 / Website redesign and SEO

Build and test on a staging site

  • Keep staging behind access control during development. If a public preview uses noindex, Google must be able to crawl the page to see that instruction; robots.txt blocking alone does not guarantee exclusion from Search.
  • At launch, remove staging-only restrictions from production pages intended for search. Preserve intentional protection for private, admin and preview pages.
  • Test every redirect on your list, especially your top pages
  • Check that titles, descriptions, headings and structured data have carried over
  • Test forms, phone links and tracking before the site goes live

05 / Website redesign and SEO

Launch-day checks

  • Redirects return the right status and land on the right page
  • Production pages intended for search are crawlable and have no accidental noindex directive.
  • The new sitemap is submitted in Search Console
  • Verify enquiry handling and measurement with clearly labelled test submissions, keeping test activity out of business reports.
  • The 404 page works, and internal links do not point to redirected URLs

06 / Website redesign and SEO

After launch: watch and fix

Google warns that rankings can fluctuate while it recrawls and reindexes the site, and that for a medium-sized site a move to new URLs can take a few weeks or more. Do not panic in week one, and do not stop checking.

  • Review the Search Console pages report and crawl errors every few days at first
  • Compare clicks, impressions and enquiries with your baseline every week
  • Fix broken links and missing redirects as you find them
  • Keep redirects in place for as long as possible, generally at least a year

07 / Website redesign and SEO

When a redesign is not the answer

Sometimes the design is fine and the real problem is traffic, messaging or a slow page. If so, targeted changes cost less and carry less risk than a full redesign. The service page on website redesign sets out when each option fits.

Buyer checklist

What to agree before your redesign starts

Ask your delivery team to include these items in the project plan:

  • A list of pages being retained, rewritten, merged or removed.
  • A named person responsible for URL decisions and launch checks.
  • A review of the enquiry journey before launch.
  • A handover covering access, updates and ongoing responsibilities.
  • An agreed period for checking the site after launch, with a clear process for reporting problems.

These details help you compare proposals and understand what the redesign includes.

Frequently asked questions

Will a redesign hurt my Google rankings?

Yes, a redesign can affect Google rankings and organic traffic, especially if URLs, content, redirects or internal links change. Careful planning—reviewing pages, preserving content that performs, mapping changed URLs, testing 301 redirects and monitoring after launch—can reduce avoidable losses, but cannot guarantee rankings or traffic will stay the same.

Do I need 301 redirects if my URLs stay the same?

No. Redirects are only needed for URLs that change. If every URL stays the same, still check that titles, headings and internal links have not been lost.

How long should I keep redirects?

Google says to keep redirects for as long as possible, generally at least one year.

Should I change my domain at the same time as the redesign?

Avoid it unless you have to. A domain change brings its own checks, and combining both makes it harder to see what caused any drop.

Sources and further reading

Related pages

A good place to begin.

Tell us what you are thinking about. Call or message us directly, or share a project brief when you are ready.